This is an unstructured analysis about The Catcher in the Rye by JD Salinger, particularly about Holden Caulfield. He’s a complex character, and some review discusses how they hated Holden Caulfield’s personality, how he’s “unreliable and annoying.” But I guess you can’t force yourself to give this book a thumbs up if you can’t relate; it’s just a matter of perspective. As for me, I like that it’s written in the first-person point of view because it holds the character’s original thoughts, including the profanities and slang, and not just the bird’s eye view of his behavior. Holden might go through series of puzzles when he talks about his feelings, but it adds up to the truthfulness and the essence of the book where it gets you into feeling what it’s like to be misunderstood and lost in a place full of “phonies.” I have included some parts of the book as reference so if you haven’t read CITR, this would definitely be a spoiler.
Basically, Holden Caulfield is a teenager who associates growing up with change, something he couldn’t handle. He’s also angsty and impulsive, but that is apparent even on the first chapter of the book, an essential part of narration to charm his way through getting the reader’s attention. Somewhere around the book, I always catch phrases like “I don’t give a damn” or “I didn’t care much” wherein he starts complaining about something that irritates him, followed by contradicting words like he’s somewhat indifferent. He hates most things though, but is irrational when it comes to explaining them. He’s aware he’s acting strange but doesn’t know what to do with himself and couldn’t help it.
I think his struggle with finding someone decent to talk to was a crushing disappointment for him, seeing as how he tried dropping clues but they repel at his words and end up missing his point. It could also be because his character gets disagreeable at times, the way he incessantly asks “immature” questions. He failed on four out of five of his subjects and and when one of his teachers tried to talk to him about it, he dismisses it because he fears the kind of confrontation that talks about his future, another thing he couldn’t face. Multiple times the word depressed was mentioned along with lonesome, quiet and lousy. These usually come up when he gets around to anything close to him thinking about his current state in life. He wants to get away as much as possible, even developed suicidal thoughts or mainly wishes to have another life so people would leave him to his own devices. He has a wealthy family but sometimes feels guilt over being privileged. I can’t say he has a good relationship with his parents, because if that’s the case then he wouldn’t feel afraid to go home and stall his way, getting drunk and chain smoking by himself around New York. He thinks he should give his parents space to absorb the news, especially his mom because she gets very hysterical (his words). He describes his mom as nervous and a heavy smoker – things he has acquired, I guess, although he doesn’t want to say it out loud. “Mothers are all slightly insane” was expressed by Holden on the book, which I think was either his deep-rooted thoughts about his mom or his ignorance about motherhood in general. He wants to save himself from being stained with “phoniness” although he may appear hypocritical at times, seeing as how he is sarcastic and somewhat a compulsive liar.
He has notions about women, but he doesn’t entirely understand sex because he is inexperienced. How by choice he has avoided to perform-a concealed fear, one of the acts of maturity he stays away from. (“I think if you don’t really like a girl, you shouldn’t horse around with her at all..” ).
He has pure affection for his sister Phoebe and keeps on putting off talking to Jane Gallagher, but he reminisces about their childhood and how they used to share personal thoughts to each other. She’s a part of him that he’s scared to revisit, for fear of ruining a perfect memory.
All throughout he keeps on mentioning his brother Allie, his evident devotion to him a significant part of the story, putting him on the highest pedestal and above everyone else in his family. He also has a habit of degrading himself such as saying he’s a moron, quite illiterate, the only really dumb one, has a lousy vocabulary etc. His lack of self-esteem is what drives him to become impulsive which led to a lot of arguments.
Overall I think Holden is an admirable character. He knows he’s troubled, but there’s no one that he feels like he can divulge his feelings to. I think a lot of young people can relate with Holden’s anxieties about life, and how death in the family at a young age can make such a big and life-changing impact. We can empathize with his need to be sheltered from pain, frustrations about the world and himself. Young or old, we find isolation very depressing to the point where it begins to chew on our very core, like termites on wood.
I could go on writing about this book, but I think this is it for now. Please feel free to comment and write your opinions, so I may have a way of correcting some of my mistakes.